A Copyright Infringement Lawsuit Over 2 Words – “Everyday I’m”

Image-124-

A Copyright Infringement Lawsuit Over 2 Words – Everyday I’m Ridiculing

Several friends contacted me via Facebook and email to ask my opinion on this Hollywood Reporter article about Rick Ross’ copyright infringement lawsuit against LMFAO.  That was nice of them as I was unaware of this lawsuit but am interested in intellectual property (IP), creativity, originality, how we evaluate expression via law, how law is used to get relief, and other subjects that interpose music and law.

I read the HR article, got the music and listened.  My first impression was that I might have the wrong music as there seemed to be not only NO copyright infringement but NO SIMILARITY.

_____________________________________________________________________

I then read the COMPLAINT filed by Rick Ross’ attorneys.  The first sentence in the COMPLAINT that mentions “music” or “lyrics” states the following:

‘Party Rock Anthem’ copies, interpolates the lyrics, underlying music and beat of ‘Hustlin’…”

I have analyzed Rick Ross’ Hustlin’ (2006) and LMFAO’s Party Rock Anthem (2011).  I strongly disagree with the allegations in Rick Ross’ complaint, specifically that sentence, and  have drawn a few conclusions to the contrary:

Party Rock Anthem  has NOT copied the lyrics of ‘Hustlin’…”

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT copied the underlying music of ‘Hustlin’…”

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT copied the beat of ‘Hustlin’…”

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT interpolated the lyrics of ‘Hustlin’…”

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT interpolated the underlying music of ‘Hustlin’…”

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT interpolated the beat of ‘Hustlin’…”

Even though I do not understand the lawyers’ use of English in the sentence above, with respect to the music contained in these two recordings (I don’t understand “copies, interpolates” as back-to-back action verbs), I have made an earnest attempt to understand what the lawyers might have meant and that has led me to arrive at these three (3) additional points:

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT copied, interpolated the lyrics of ‘Hustlin’…”

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT copied, interpolated the underlying music of ‘Hustlin’…”

Party Rock Anthem’ has NOT copied, interpolated the beat of ‘Hustlin’…”

There is one (1) similarity I notice between the two (2) songs, however.  Both songs/recordings share two (2) identical words.  Those words are:

1.  Everyday

2.  I’m

Despite the contention from Rick Ross’ attorneys that the songs ALMOST have three (3) words in common, there are two (2), not three (3) words in common as I will demonstrate below:

Rick Ross sings, “Everyday I’m hustling.”

LMFAO sing, “Everyday I’m shuffling.”

Perhaps Rick Ross’ attorneys think that LMFAO have copied three (3) and not two (2) words.  Perhaps they are  thinking, “Everyday I’m hustling” is the same as “Everyday I’m shuffling.”  But, to my eyes, those final words of each phrase are different words with different meanings and different spellings:

HUSTLING is spelled

H-U-S-T-L-I-N-G

and

SHUFFLING is spelled

S-H-U-F-F-L-I-N-G

“Hustling” and “Shuffling” also have different meanings – here are links to the definitions from Dictionary.com:

Hustling  (the verb used by Rick Ross in 2006) means “push or force one’s way.”

Shuffling  (the verb used by LMFAO in 2011) means “moving in a dragging or clumsy manner.”

“Pushing or forcing one’s way” (“hustling”) seems to me to be the opposite of “moving in a dragging or clumsy manner” (shuffling”).  If one person hustles and another person shuffles, are they engaged in the same kind of action?  No, they are not.

The U. S. Copyright Law was created, in part, to protect “original works of authorship.”  In my opinion, the word, “everyday” is not original.  In my opinion, the word, “I’m,” is not original.  When the words are joined to form a two-word phrase – “Everyday I’m” – they still do not form original expression.

_____________________________________________________________________

To “go all factual on you” for a moment – LMFAO sing “everyday I’m shuffling” (not “everyday I’m hustling”) only twice in “Party Rock Anthem.”  This three-word phrase occurs at the following two places in “Party Rock Anthem:”

2.15 – 2.16  “everyday I’m shuffling'”

3.47 – 3.49  “everyday I’m shuffling'”  (“shuffling” with a slight elongation/added syllable)

A reasonable person could conclude that:

1.  “Everyday I’m shuffling” occurs only twice in Party Rock Anthem.

2.  “Everyday I’m shuffling” is not very important to Party Rock Anthem.

3.  One had an opinion about Party Rock Anthem well before one heard “Everyday I’m shuffling” at 2.15 into the song.

4.  “Everyday I’m shuffling” is not the same phrase as “everyday I’m hustling.”

I toyed with these other titles for this post:

There’s Stupid & Then There’s Rick Ross Stupid

Rick Ross v. LMFAO – So This Is How (these) Florida Attorneys Sue

Why hasn’t Rick Ross sued Maysa, Jeremy Fisher or Little Big?

I’m glad I settled on A Copyright Infringement Lawsuit Over 2 Words.

In my next post or two on this subject, I will discuss some suggestions I have for Rick Ross and his attorneys regarding the music of Maysa, Jeremy Fisher and Little Big.  If money matters to Rick Ross and his attorneys, I imagine they’ll be thrilled at what I’ll be able to show them.  This new knowledge could lead them to new copyright infringement lawsuits and procure more billable hours for themselves and/or their law firm(s).

But the hand (silly mind) that giveth might taketh away as well as I have potentially bad news for Rick Ross.  Using the same or similar reasoning and quality of evidence, in future posts I will describe scenarios and analyze and discuss music that could negate any happy gains Rick Ross might enjoy in his lawsuit against LMFAO.  Perhaps Rick Ross himself could even be sued for copyright infringement.

The next post though should be happy happy for Rick Ross.

The points of these posts are simply to examine expression from the viewpoints of originality, creativity and law, and critique musical/textual/legal arguments espoused by others.  (I am not a party to this lawsuit or affiliated with any party in this lawsuit.  Therefore, I feel it is appropriate to weigh in on the matters presented in this case.)

_____________________________________________________________________  

 

6 Replies to “A Copyright Infringement Lawsuit Over 2 Words – “Everyday I’m””

  1. Sbobet is a trusted gambling site that operates to abet
    all fans of online gambling in the world.
    Founded in 2010, it didn’t acknowledge long for Sbobet to become the biggest online site in Asia and past it comes to
    the amount of betting money that rotates every week, Sbobet
    is then one of the biggest sites in the world.

    Sbobet is utterly popular, especially among Asian bettors, the reason is that the site
    has been awarded as the best gambling operator
    for two years in a row. It offers a variant of football betting bearing in mind unquestionably low margins gone compared to supplementary
    sites in its class.

  2. The best in class, Depoxito come up with the money for you high-end experience that focus on the look and setting of legitimate
    VIP standarts, we pay for you the best captivating to high-level experience of
    VIPs expect in any summit stop casino, grand breathing casino royale have enough money you
    the additional studio design element including the grand blackjack, offering our VIP Customer
    the best experience of a Salon privee table.
    New style table along with feature across the room following grand roulette upgraded upon our provider playtechs
    mini prestige roulette which delivering more interesting and richer playing experience.
    The additional experience contains a sum of seven tables including five blackjack tables,
    one roulette table and one baccarat table. Grand rouse casino royale
    has been high hand-engineered to fit the needs of our customer to using it, and contains unique elements that is specially
    designed to maximize the impact value we got from our customers and diversify it to the existing network.

    Soon, Depoxito will build an greater than before realism technology on rouse casino
    for our VIP member, these most ahead of its time technology ever seen in stimulate
    casino including this improved reality. Which allow players
    to experience products on an entire supplementary level which is
    never seen previously literally leaping out of the game and taking the blackjack, baccarat, roulette and
    additional game into the amassed entire level.
    Depoxito VIP Baccarat, we give you the very exclusive stimulate VIP Baccarat
    that is played past going on to 7 players at the similar
    table and our extremely trained beautiful conscious baccarat dealer.
    And of course our VIP advocate will quality as if they were in fact
    sitting at one of the summit casino baccarat table. This immersive gaming experience creates a hugely carefree tune that our VIP players
    will locate hard to surpass.
    Here is the list of conscious casino game that depoxito provide, we have enough money the widest range
    of living casino games on the announce including : blackjack unlimited,
    blackjack prestige, roulette, baccarat, poker, hi-lo,
    sic bo, and grand bring to life casino royale such as Grand Baccarat, Grand Blackjack
    and Grand Roulette for our VIP member. And of course as a member of Depoxito you can enjoy
    every the games that we find the money for to you, all you compulsion to realize is just
    visit our site depoxito and register it
    by yourself takes in the works to 3 minutes
    and next youre normal to play a part any game that you want.

    Be our VIP, visceral our VIP fanatic of course arranged
    you the best foster you can acquire from us every you need to be a VIP believer
    is enormously easy. every you habit is just save playing upon our site, accrual and
    show like a VIP later the amount that our company had written, keep playing and
    our customer assist will contact you that you are promoted
    to become a VIP zealot on our site.

  3. Exploring all online gambling game on the internet has become one of the happenings most
    enjoyed by users of gambling services nowadays. How not, all the games
    that used to be forlorn enjoyed abroad by people from
    the upper classes, now you can enjoy without having to depart the home and use a more affordable cost to do its stuff slot gambling in the house.

    This is all thanks to internet technology that can border online gambling fans in the same way
    as the best gambling relief providers nearly the world. As in Indonesia itself,
    the recognized online gambling agent site like Depoxito is here to foster those
    of you who want to spend free epoch like character online
    gambling products.

    Since its presence in the domestic online gambling
    industry, Depoxito has presented various types of gambling games
    of the highest quality. Games such as soccer betting,
    casino, shooting fish, poker, lottery, and of course online slot games are available in imitation of international standards because
    they arrive from leading gambling sites such as Sbobet, Spade Gaming,
    Microgaming, Playtech, and suitably on.

    For those of you who want to attempt out how venturesome it is to
    show online gambling on the qualified gambling agent website
    Depoxito, immediately register now and enjoy the best online gambling experience
    that you can’t find anywhere else.

  4. within acceptable limits and thank you for visiting online casino agents for Indonesia.

    Here we are here to allow entrance for fans of sbobet casino who want to link the international agent site Promosbobet.

    The products offered are categorically diverse and are
    agreed the best choice. Derived from providers that have credibility and have been proven to have the best predicate in serving their
    customers. Providers as soon as Sbobet, Maxbet and many more.

    As the best online casino and soccer gambling site in Indonesia.
    We offer maximum help next customer keep that works online 24 full hours all day.
    correspondingly members can discharge duty whenever and wherever
    without fearing to face the possibility of difficulties or
    confusion.

  5. Mabosbet has been present in the best soccer gambling site industry for a long time,
    presenting various kinds of soccer games for fans in Indonesia from various walks of life.
    Games easy to get to at Mabosbet enlarge the most popular games such as guessing scores to
    daring exotic gambling games such as Asian Handicap and blend Parlay.

    Customer sustain is active 24 hours a daylight and can be contacted easily through various methods including enliven chat directly from the
    official website, proving that we are the best online gambling agent site in the same way as the most professional
    service. Register yourself now and enjoy the gambling game subsequently millions of members from all beyond the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *